There are several types of dog anxiety. Pet ownership, rewarding as it can be. There is also a biological explanation for emotional contagion. John Bowlby, a British psychiatrist, psychologist, and psychoanalyst,[23]is credited as being the principal developer of attachment theory. However, the research presented thus far evaluated only human-human relationships. July 2005. It is unlikely that the experimental dogs were previously exposed to any of the odors. Children of parents scoring high on attachment avoidance were more distressed during the inoculation than children of parents scoring low on avoidance. Owner attachment and problem behaviors related to relinquishment and training techniques of dogs. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 3, 179-201., [41]Salman, M.D., New Jr., J.C., Scarlett, J.M., Kass, P.H., Ruch-Gallie, R. and Hetts, S. (1998) Human and Animal Fac- tors Related to the Relinquishment of Dogs and Cats in 12 Selected Animal Shelters in the United States. They are a proprietary adaptation from existing validated evaluation protocols, information presented during scientific conferences and in research papers, and customized innovations created by CPT. [CrossRef], [107], [108]Tuijl, L; Glashouwer, K; Bockting, C; Tendeiro, J; Penninx, B; deJong, P.  Implicit and Explicit Self-Esteem in Current, Remitted, Recovered, and Comorbid Depression and Anxiety Disorders: The NESDA Study. Vol. I hate seeing him debilitated and I hated feeling trapped in the house having to take care of him for weeks on end. Dec 7, 2018. Share This Story. Our tears remind us that the joy we shared is now a memory, and we mourn the loss of our daily interactions of caring, loving and being loved. Therefore, such dogs have a high probability of engaging calmly and proximally with the confident owner, rather than defending aggressively when the dog observes the approach of an interloper, in comparison to dogs owned by less confident owners or owners exhibiting less secure attachment patterns. 58 (5): 823–831. ; Patall, E.A. I feel like a terrible dog owner although I am doing what I truly can, handling expenses on my own and treating him as recommended, and I am constantly … In succinct terms, the lifestyle and actions characteristic of a severely neurotic owner may contribute to the neuroses, anxious behavior, and aggressive behavior exhibited by a dog. Volume 4, Issue 7.Pg 252-254., [80], [81]Preston, S.D. Yet, early productive social exposure to people, dogs, and multifarious environments is vital to the emotional development of a young dog. Moreover, aggression and submissiveness were the most consistent of the measured dimensions. Persons who exhibit a neurotic and avoidant attachment style negatively impact the emotional state and behavior of their dog. 48 (1): 26–34. 25 (1): 26–33. [63], From an appearance standpoint, the foxes displayed spotted coats; floppy ears; curled tails; thicker limbs, and shorter, rounder muzzles. Therefore, satisfaction and attraction lead to perceptions of similarity., [95]Morry, M.  Relationship Satisfaction as a Predictor of Similarity Ratings: A Test of the Attraction Similarity Hypothesis. Influence of Owners’ Attachment Style and Personality on Their Dogs’ (Canis familiaris) Separation-Related Disorder. As a therapist myself, I knew what I was feeling was normal but it was hard to deal with often alone. Dec 2013, Jan 2016, June 2018). In summary, people appear to apply the attraction-similarity hypothesis when selecting pets. ; Sinn, D.L. PLoS One. Or are all the preceding causations true? CPT individual dog evaluations thoroughly examine 50 criteria. While it is said euthanizing a pet is one of the most loving and humane decisions you can make, it’s one that is never easy and it inevitably brings about an array of challenging emotions. Evolution:  Education and Outreach. There is a high correlation between canine anxiety and aggressive behavior. Furthermore, when frightened or startled by a novel object in the presence of the maternal figure, the young monkeys experienced less anxiety and either explored the object or sought the caregiver as a secure base. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.85.4.709. [53]Suomi SJ. With our dying human relatives, we have no choice but to accept not knowing what the future holds as we await their final breath. I have buried many of my dearest beloved companions, I have fought the good fight with them through multiple diseases, I have paid thousands of dollars to try to make them well again. The owner slowly introduces the dog to the source of anxiety, preferably in small doses and at a decreased intensity. A dog that tends to be clingy and who needs constant reassurance from his owner, combined with any of the above signs, is a likely candidate for separation anxiety and it is important to seek professional help. There are many factors that lead to interpersonal attraction, including physical attraction, propinquity (frequency of proximal exposure), familiarity, similarity, complementarity, reciprocal liking, and reinforcement. For instance, an infant separated from a maternal figure at birth and raised in an orphanage will likely have less opportunity to develop secure attachment than an infant raised in a typical maternal-child environment. The overall finding is that owners who are neurotic, emotionally disconnected, less controlling, or less structured are more likely to possess dogs exhibiting aggressive behavior. Recent research tends to agree with CPT’s opinion. Photo Credit: Mark Spivak and Patricia King. Scientific Reports. Would you rather handle a relaxed dog or an aggressive dog? [45]  In addition, those raised exclusively by wire surrogates commonly experienced diarrhea. [75]  Theories of coevolution between humans and dogs explain how humans became more adept at interpreting canine communication and more socially bonded with dogs as the species evolved from wolves into the many breeds of the contemporary domestic dog., [92], [93], [94]Dr. Marian M. Morry. However, despite disparity in race creating an obstacle to interaction, by placing persons of different races in proximal residences the likelihood of interaction increased threefold. doi:10.1002/dev.420260704. Developmental Psychology. She has good moments throughout the day, still enjoys her walks, plays with her toys – most of my family and friends comment that she appears to be in good health. [69]Elfenbein, HA. Appl. Pet Owner Anxiety: The Challenges Associated with Loving a Pet. 2010, 124, 104–112. In an excellent experiment that observed the social behavior of mice, independent of pheromonal input, gonadal hormones, opponents, or social context, excitation of progesterone-receptor-expressing neurons in the ventromedial hypothalamus triggered territorial aggression in solitary male mice, but did not elicit territorial aggression in socially housed males, unless their pheromone-sensing was disabled. Frontiers in Veterinary Science, Feb 26, 2018. Behav. • The wolves that were bold but aggressive were killed by humans. In a sample group at Dartmouth College, geographic proximity and race were greater determinants of social interaction than were common interests, majors, or family background. Separation Anxiety Peeing in Dogs Separation anxiety peeing in dogs. [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar],, [32]Schoeberl I, Wedl M, Bauer B, Day J, Moestl E, Kotrschal K. Effects of owner-dog relationship and owner personality on cortisol modulation in human-dog dyads. Emotional contagion is the phenomenon of having one person’s emotions and related behaviors directly trigger similar emotions and behaviors in other people. Administrative Science Quarterly. Does personality, delinquency, or mating e↵ort necessarily dictate a preference for an aggressive dog? • 45% of dogs abandoned to shelters are less than 1 year of age and 60% are less than 2 years of age. Behav. Subscribe. Yet I’m still struck by how stressed, lost, and guilty I’ve felt regarding truly knowing what steps to take between now and then—and how this dilemma, or any type of stress related to pet ownership, is something I’ve rarely heard others voice. 348, Issue 6232, pg 333-336., [79]Gallese, V; Goldman, A. Just like human beings, dogs endure anxiety; this may be unpleasant, but it’s normal. As discussed in previous sections, early socialization is focal to preventing the formation of canine anxiety and aggression. }(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk')); Call us today to enroll: (404) 236-2150 or email:, To learn more about CPT’s boarding and board training services or to make a reservation, please contact CPT by phone at, Copyright © 2002 (Rev. Hopefully, by now, you will see how many potential variables there are when trying to devise ‘catch-all’ solutions to this most common of problems. An attachment perspective on human-pet relationships: conceptualization and assessment of pet attachment orientations. Volume 125. Moreover, such aggressive occurrences subject the owner to increased anxiety, a risk of cancellation of homeowner’s or renter’s insurance policies, animal control violations, civil financial liability, contempt from neighbors, conflicts with landlords and homeowners’ associations, and a reduction in enjoyment of the person’s pet owning experience. Furthermore, we should expect that an owner exhibiting a secure attachment style will have the most psychological healthy and emotionally stable pet, whereas an owner exhibiting an avoidant or disorganized attachment style should have the most maladaptive and emotionally unstable pet. PBS. A CPT consultation can assist the owner in properly evaluating all major factors (health, husbandry, behavior) relevant to the decision whether to neuter/spay the dog and, if so, when. [CrossRef], [34]Konok, V.; Kosztolányi, A.; Rainer, W.; Mutschler, B.; Halsband, U.; Miklósi, Á. All rights reserved. 2013, 20, 199–215. [CrossRef], [106]Meyer, I.; Forkman, B. Furthermore, the innate human ability to recognize and respond to dog communication is improved via experience and a positive attitude toward the dog.[74]. This is very important as it gives the owner a sense of responsibility to care for their pet and also provides a distraction from anxiety. Neuron 2017, 95, 955–970. Frans de Waal, an acclaimed primatologist and ethologist, cites examples of simulation theory in multiple species, including dogs. PMID 12625087., [82]Preston, S.D. Relatsh. Animal Cognition. doi:10.1159/000071465. The Importance of Early Emotional Bonds”. Administrative Science Quarterly. Appl. However, if immersion was delayed until after the critical period of development (3 months), then the social, emotional, and behavioral deficits usually remained permanent. Vet. [46], Moreover, the experiment showed that other than during brief periods of hunger tactile contact and the feeling of security were valued higher than was feeding. But I find I am constantly worrying now about my other 2 cats. The Conclusion:  Is There a Bidirectional Relationship Between Dog-Owner Anxiety? Separation anxiety occurs when a dog is hyper-attached to the owner, meaning that the dog gets very stressed and anxious. 25 (1): 1–20, discussion 20–71. Yet, even when the human does not intentionally collaborate with the dog’s anxious emotional state and behavior, the human may inadvertently and undesirably share the dog’s anxiety. But what about insecure parent-child and owner-dog attachment styles? In a study that addressed anxiety in dogs, it was found that 72.5% of all subjects exhibited some form of anxiety-like behaviour. One of the more intriguing impressions is the apparent correlation between anxious owners and dogs exhibiting anxiety, aggressive behavior, or both. For the past few months her condition has begun to deteriorate and the vet bills are getting more expensive every month. and Hutchison, J.M. [24], Attachment theory is an enduring psychological connection with a meaningful person that forms pleasure responses and provides security in times of stress. Vol 56 Issue 43 Pets anxiety dogs. PMID 25111305,, [6]Norris CJ, Larsen JT, Cacioppo JT (September 2007). [Google Scholar], [17]Rehn, T.; Beetz, A.; Keeling, L.J. Anim Cogn. July 31, 2012. & de Wall, F.B.M. Dec 2002. [108], Consequently, anxious persons who question their worthiness purposefully select a dog mirroring their personality type. Primatol., 2: 319–342. Thank you for writing this, I haven’t been able to label what I’ve been feeling related to my dogs and pet owner anxiety is just that. Copyright © 2007 - 2020 GoodTherapy, LLC. The efficiency of the Do as I do method and shaping/clicker training method to train dogs. The analysis provides evidence that dogs resemble their owners.[9]. Dear Megan, I know you wrote this article several years ago and I hope all is well with you. Behav. Moreover, given what we know about coevolution, emotional contagion, mirror neurons, and simulation theory of empathy, an owner predisposed to anxiety is likely to succumb to the dog’s intentions. Some researchers have doubted the validity of litter evaluations and several influential persons with a political agenda have publicly doubted the accuracy of shelter dog evaluations. Anxiety creates an aroused emotional state that predisposes a dog to a greater probability of manifesting out of context aggressive behavior. [Google Scholar], [38]Kwan JY, Bain MJ. 2013;16(2):168–183. Dmitry Belyaev was a Russian geneticist who in 1959 was quested with improving the production at silver fox farms, as fox fur was very popular in Russia. [96]  Individuals often project their own attitudes, behaviors, or relationship views onto close others, which influences relationship judgments. The Importance of Early Emotional Bonds”. [111], Meta-analyses of the findings pertaining to inter-rater agreement, test-retest reliability, internal consistency, and convergent validity generally support the validity of canine temperament tests.[112]. CPT has no conflict of interest when assessing the relevant variables and presenting research information. Psychophysiology. ((1). Yet, the newer research shows the previous belief may be true in the small minority of male dogs exhibiting true dominance aggression, but is false for the much larger number of male dogs exhibiting anxious temperaments, who frequently exhibit more pronounced anxiety and fear-aggression post a neuter surgery. [64][65], The experiment also found genetic anatomical and physiologically based causation for the foxes’ rapid evolution. [CrossRef], [59]MacLean, EL; Snyder-Mackler, N; vonHoldt, BM; Serpell, JA. • Friendliness changed their appearance.They started to develop splotchy coats, floppy ears, and wagging tails. From the standpoint of purposeful communication of emotions and behavior, an anxiously aggressive dog may wish its owner to align with it, which would strengthen the pack’s response to repel the stimulus. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. [91]  The Complementary Principle may apply in certain owner-dog dyads. Personal Relationships. Drugs in Context. Any views and opinions expressed are not necessarily shared by ; Finkel, E.J., [64]Wade, Nicholas (25 July 2006). March 5, 2020., [55]Puurunen, J; Hakanen, E; Salonen, M; Mikkola, S; Sulkama, S; Araujo, C; Lohi, H.  Inadequate Socialisation, Inactivity, and Urban Living Environments are Associated with Social Fearfulness in Pet Dogs. The answer to both questions is, “It depends.”  It depends upon the purchaser or adopter’s temperament, attachment style, schedule, residence, family composition, and lifestyle characteristics. Prior sections discussed how neurotic owners can create anxious dogs, how owners with an avoidant attachment style can create anxious dogs, and how anxious dogs can instigate owners to become acutely or chronically anxious. A study found significant positive correlations between owners and their dogs in all 5 personality dimensions (neuroticism, extraversion, conscientiousness, agreeableness, and openness). Regardless, the presence of a neurotic owner increases the probability the dog will exhibit anxiety and associated aggression and that the owner will have reduced capability and maybe even reduced desire to properly control the animal. ; Pearl, D.L. • After modern humans arrived in Europe 43,000 years ago, they pretty much wiped out every large carnivore that existed. [29]  There is evidence for an owner-specific secure base effect in dogs[30]. 71(9): 1187-1195., [12]Koyuncu, A; Ince, E; Ertekin, E; Tukel, R. Comorbidity in Social Anxiety Disorder: Diagnostic and Therapeutic Challenges. Second, stress reduced the animal’s breeding frequency and litter health. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.72.2.362. ; Goodman, G.S. Issues 3 – 4. ; Brodbelt, D.C.; O’Neill, D. Mortality resulting from undesirable behaviours in dogs aged under three years attending primary-care veterinary practices in England. [104]Botwin, M. D.; Buss, D. M.; Shackelford, T. K. (1997). More from The Onion. [4]  In the model, neuroticism is defined as a proclivity to exhibit distress and negative emotions, such as fear, sadness, anger, anxiety, irritability, loneliness, worry, self-consciousness, dissatisfaction, hostility, shyness, low self-confidence, and vulnerability,[5]whereupon the person exhibits nervousness, has low tolerance for stress or aversive situations or stimuli, and displays emotionally instability.[6]. My other dog began having issues as well and thus the cycle continued. The video below entitled Similarity Attraction Theory describes the validation process: Thus, in the past three sections we showed strong evidence that all three causations posited in Section I have relevance. CPT in-home private lessons are a terrific resource for teaching owners strategies how to prevent housebreaking and household manners problems or resolve existing problems. [86]  To apply the Proximity Principal to an owner-pet scenario, regardless of the temperament characteristics of the dog and owner, they are likely to bond with one another simply by residing together, provided one or both do not have a highly maladaptive temperament or attachment style. I can relate to this completely (I found this thread because I googled ‘always worrying about pets’). Domestic dogs have advanced abilities to respond to human behaviors or expectations. In simulated separation anxiety, the dog knows that he will get attention if … Dogs owned by persons considering them “social partners” and “meaningful companions” showed lower salivary cortisol levels than dogs owned by persons having a more distant relationship with their pets. It was a stressful time. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. “Rapid mimicry and emotional contagion in domestic dogs”. [101]Klohnen, E. C.; Luo, S. (2003). College students believe their opposite-gender friends to be similar to themselves, although these beliefs may be a perception of the partner’s similarity, rather than an accurate assessment. Altruism in Wolves Explains the Coevolution of Dogs and Wolves. I had feelings of anger as well. While operating CPT for the past 30 years I have availed myself of many anecdotal observations. Anxiety certainly inhibits the quality of life of a pet, especially when contrasted to the quality of life expected from a more confident animal. [100]  Actual security and self-security predicted attraction. 2011;45(4):345–357. Therefore, Belyaev reasoned that if he selected animals for tameness and only bred the tame animals, then over generations they would be easier to handle and more prodigious in producing frequent litters, larger litters, and healthier puppies. July 2005. May 2016. How To Calm A Dog With Separation Anxiety. Psychol. The preceding article was solely written by the author named above. How Do Friendships Form? 4) Disorganized attachment– occurs when the primary caregiver inconsistently varies in response to the child. Combining the results from the preceding studies, dogs can be genotyped with a predisposition toward developing anxiety and aggression and fearful dogs are more predisposed toward developing aggressive behavior toward unfamiliar persons and dogs. js = d.createElement(s); = id; • Abandoned dogs were more likely than continued dogs to be kept all day in a crate.[42]. Dog breeds which tend to have lots of separation anxiety include: The Labrador Retriever. This involves changing how the dog perceive pre-departure cues (e.g. CPT’s protocols, usually administered via private and in-home private lessons, provide the highest probability of modifying general anxiety, state anxiety, and aggressive behavior. Although these problems often indicate that a dog needs to be taught polite house manners, they can also be symptoms of distress. [103]  Individuals prefer mates similar to themselves.[104]. I need to learn how to deal with it somehow but I don’t know how. Regardless, despite feeling fearful, few owners will want their dog to deliver a bite injury to an undeserving person or dog victim. Rec. Sci. Feb 5, 2017., [49]Zhang, B; Suarez-Jimenez, B; Hathaway, A; Waters, C; Vaughan, K; Noble, P; Fox, N; Suomi, S; Pine, D; Nelson, E. Developmental Changes in Rhesus Monkeys in Response to Separation from the Mother. Royal Society Open Science. Dog anxiety is stressful for dogs and humans alike. The foxes that reacted aggressively were removed from the experiment, whereas the foxes that reacted least were selected for breeding. Findings support the existence of an interspecies oxytocin-mediated positive loop facilitated and modulated by gazing, which supports the coevolution of human-dog bonding by engaging common modes of communicating social attachment.[78]. CPT Head Trainers specialize in scientific-based behavior modification training focused on human-dog communication, general impulse control, counterconditioning, and systematic desensitization principles. Animal Cognition. Persons with social anxiety are more likely to avoid social contact with persons, neighborhood dogs, and many environmental contexts. Notwithstanding the anxious owner’s preferences, the dilemma is exacerbated by the probability that anxious people are less likely to enroll their dog in a training program and are intrinsically less capable of handling and managing their dog. 2004, 6, 31–52. These findings strongly support the need for an immediate re-evaluation of the current recommendation to spay or neuter dogs to prevent or treat behavioral problems, and an equally pressing need to more fully examine the wide range of physical effects of spaying and neutering pet dogs. Complementarity and interpersonal rigidity were examined in relation to positive regard for others and group integration among 206 members of 54 musical bands. Animal Cognition. 2014;17(2):373–385. By commenting you acknowledge acceptance of's Terms and Conditions of Use. Bibcode:2015RSOS….250505P. Animals. But for me, the greatest anxiety has come with navigating the options, recommendations, and uncertainty after finding out my dog’s health is failing. [34], Pet avoidant attachment consists of feelings of discomfort with physical and emotional closeness. The Silver Fox Domestication Experiment. “The Collective Construction of Work Group Moods”. Only the ones that were bold and friendly were tolerated. Owners can present a secure base for their dogs. Moreover, the power of emotional contagion is not exclusive to neuroticism. Your dog will benefit from you being less anxious, too. 45 (2): 197–231. Moreover, CPT’s involvement in preventive and treatment measures improves the human-animal bond, owner satisfaction of the pet owning experience, and the quality of life for both the owner and dog. The benefit of including complementary persons depends upon the flexibility of existing members. Moreover, in line with the above human and dog examples, despite that fact that both positive and negative emotions can be contagious,[70]there are more behavioral indicators for arousal with negative valence states and sounds. They evolved their ability to read human gestures. “Do birds of a feather universally flock together? [32]  A lower level of salivary cortisol indicates a lower level of stress and a generally healthier animal, physically, physiologically, and psychologically. Pet owners who feel insecurely attached to their pet tend to view the pet as having negative or troubling characteristics, mistrust their pet’s intentions, and don’t expect the pet to be available, sensitive, and responsive to their needs. J Res Pers. Anyone who makes that decision is truly brave. 2013., [14]Yang, T.; Yang, C.F. ; Coe, J.B.; Serpell, J.A. June 1964., [90], [91]O’Connor, Brian; Dyce, J. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry. ; Ganguli, S.; et al. Neutered dogs were more aggressive, fearful, excitable and less trainable than intact dogs. Each time she becomes ill with some new infection (due to her reliance on steroids and other immunosuppressants) I pay hundreds of dollars for more bloodwork and more prescriptions. The British Medical Journal. “Nice Rats, Nasty Rats: Maybe It’s All in the Genes”. This enjoyable video provides a practical explanation of Bowlby’s attachment styles and their impact throughout a person’s social and emotional life: Thus, the attachment style of a parent can have great effects on the personality development and associated behavior of a child. Professor. Nevertheless, regardless of the owner’s or dog’s characteristics, once the owner learns to effectively administer human-dog leadership communication, then the owner will have greater impact in positively affecting the dog’s behavior, which includes greater control of potential aggressive propensities. Science. [55], Moreover, there is a correlation between anxiety and the development of aggressive behavior. Extrapolating further, both from a theoretical and practical perspective the probability is extremely high that a dog concerned by a stimulus could intentionally or inadvertently transmit an anxious emotional state to a human owner and perhaps even aggressive behavior to a human owner. I wish they could just be okay but I find it hard to see a good future for them although their lives have improved in recent years. Nov 11, 2019., [75]Bartel, C. A.; Saavedra, R. (2000). For those interested learning more about emotional contagion and mirror neurons, you may wish to view this PBS video: In summary, the evidence is strong that neurotic dogs can chronically and acutely create anxious owners. However, if a client first contacts CPT after a dog exhibits anxious traits or aggressive behavior or if prevention is insufficient, then treatment is indicated. March 3, 2013., [77]Jouventin, P; Christen, Y; Dobson, FS. I think that suffering through the loss of pets is one of the most difficult experiences we may have, yet we learn from this how precious life is, and how unique each creature is on this globe. One of the most devastating parts of pet ownership is coming to terms with the fact we will likely have to say goodbye to our beloved companions whose lifespans just don’t equal ours. Developmental Neuroscience. However, after changes in leadership communication, some impulse control drills, improved leash walking mechanics, and several counterconditioning and systematic desensitization drills he can now behave calmly proximal to unfamiliar people and dogs. Thank you for the article. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.48.1.26. Criteria categories include affiliation with familiar persons, affiliation with unfamiliar persons, tolerance of tactile contact, tolerance of restraint, tolerance of discomfort, noise tolerance, tolerance of unfamiliar and moving objects, proprioceptive confidence and competence, tolerance of outdoor stimuli, behavior amidst unfamiliar dogs, tolerance of isolation, play drive, food drive, olfactory ability, problem solving ability, general energy, general cooperation, and general health and structure. Consequently, aggressive behavior causes the anxious-aggressive dog to suffer a diminished quality of life. To access the article, entitled “Recent Research Raises Concerns Regarding Early Spaying/Neutering,” please click the link in this sentence. Owning a pet for me has been one of the single best experiences of my life. The anxiety I experienced due to my worry about her spread into other areas of my life. The nature of love. [40], • 96% of abandoned dogs had not attended obedience classes or received professional training.[41]. However, her condition requires multiple medications daily, intermittent small meals, and regular bloodwork and checkups. Dev. All rights reserved. [16]  Dogs may develop different strategies to handle challenging situations, based on the type of support they get from their owner. Psychiatric Clinics of North America. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Personality consistency in dogs: A meta–analysis. [99]  The crucial determinant of interactional satisfaction was neither the mood of the subject nor the mood of the partner, but their similarity in mood. Anim. British Psychological Society. Practice Management Software for Therapists, Rules and Ethics of Online Therapy for Therapists, How to Send Appointment Reminders that Work. Dogs owned by persons scoring high in neuroticism were less successful at operational tasks. When is it okay to put my mental health ahead of my dog’s life? Quarterly Journal of Economics. 2017,197, 45–54. This helps to prevent anxiety escalation and is accomplished through habituation, counter-conditioning and desensitisation which are explained … Subscribe me to the public newsletter. For instance, an anxious, meek owner, who feels unsafe around people, may purposefully seek an aggressive animal to acquire a greater feeling of security and power. Inopportune or inappropriate social exposures may be traumatic and highly counterproductive. Training improves satisfaction with the animal, diminishes the likelihood of behavioral problems that produce dissatisfaction and/or emotional distance, and reduces the likelihood of rehoming. Do neurotic dogs make their owners anxious? The preceding is consistent with a caretaker avoidant attachment style and the developmental response to such a style. [99]Heine, Steven J; Foster, Julie-Ann B.; Spina, Roy (2009). It feels like a never-ending nightmare honestly. Hum. Dogs behave similarly to children toward their mothers:  owners are the preferred recipients of affiliative behaviors. [57], Aggression toward unfamiliar dogs and people arises most commonly from fear and territoriality. The attachment style may result from the parent being raised in a neglectful or abusive household. The decision still haunts me but deep within I know it was the most compassionate thing I could have done for her. Developmental Psychology. [CrossRef], [18]Merola I, Prato-Previde E, Lazzaroni M, Marshall-Pescini S. Dogs’ comprehension of referential emotional expressions: familiar people and familiar emotions are easier. The children tend to mistrust the caretaker, but feel severely distressed when the caretaker is absent and joyful upon the caretaker’s return. Moreover, socialization should include interspecies (human, cat), intraspecies, and environmental exposures. 26(7): 407–420. Yet, there are a number of controllable factors, both from the standpoints of prevention and treatment, whereby CPT can decrease the probability of anxious and/or aggressive behavior or decrease the severity and resultant emotional and financial impact. J. Not only did Belyaev produce tame foxes that were calm and easy to handle, but the foxes changed in appearance and exhibited unanticipated behaviors. [CrossRef], [10]Noyes, Jr., R.  Comorbidity in Generalized Anxiety Disorder. Owners reported more positive attitudes toward their pets when the behavioral style complemented their own interpersonal style. To answer the question we need first to determine whether dogs can be inherently anxious. Proximity fosters frequency, which promotes interaction, and resultantly increases the probability of a relationship.[85]. 1997, 141, 73–76. Certainly, handling an aggressive dog can be nerve wracking, even for a normally calm person. [37], Compatible with the avoidant persons’ response to the death of a pet, persons who relinquish their dogs to shelters score lower on “companion animal attachment” than do continuing owners.[38]. Instead of acting fearfully with humans, they followed humans, wagged tails when humans approached, licked the human caretakers, allowed humans to pick them up, and whined when humans departed. The process of emotional contagion can be linked to facial mimicry and body language. Age-based anxiety. National Geographic. Persons displaying an avoidant attachment style are more likely to reside with dogs exhibiting dog-owner aggression. Sci. This contrasted of course with what was going on around me, and with my pets in particular, which has lead to me having constant stress about their life circumstances and conditions. 22(4): 561-584., [97]Morry, M.  The Attraction-Similarity Hypothesis Among Cross-Sex Friends: Relationship Satisfaction, Perceived Similarities, and Self-Serving Perceptions. First, aggressive foxes were difficult and dangerous to handle for the humans working on the farm. Dec 7, 2018., [67]Wilkins, AS; Wrangham,  RW; Fitch, WT. 20, 703-715 (2017). Ideas in Ecology and Evolution. Being a first-time dog owner, I’ve struggled with nagging questions about whether I should be doing more; confusion as to whether various vets are giving me the best advice; guilt over my hesitancy at emptying my bank account for tests that won’t change the inevitable; and dread over what those final days will be like. • The wolf was domesticated at a time when humans were not very tolerant of carnivorous competitors. But, what if both parties started anxious? N. Am. Getting little sleep due to checking on her through out the night, worried that I would come home and find her. (1997). Comprehensive Pet Therapy. Appl Anim Behav Sci. Biographical Memoirs: V. 64 (1994). [CrossRef] However, it occurred to me that I’d never really come across information regarding the anxiety that can come with owning a pet, though it’s likely something many pet owners and animal lovers experience at some point. May 29, 2013., [31]Siniscalchi M, Stipo C, Quaranta A. Typically, the owner comes back from work and is greeted by an overly excited dog. The phenomenon of spaying increasing the likelihood of aggression in female dogs was known previously, although most believed the effect insignificant. It was one of the toughest things that I have ever had to do, but I know that she will meet me again someday, so I hold onto that. “Satisfaction in interpersonal interactions as a function of similarity in level of dysphoria” (PDF). [CrossRef], [58]Haug, L.I. [68]Schoenewolf, G. (1990). Vet. However, there are also acute and chronic environmental components attributable to emotional contagion. Yet, the norms are only appropriate for the median member of the breed. ; Schaaf, J.M. Anthrozoos. [61]  Belyaev isolated 2 primary problems affecting the fox fur industry. PMID 17596178,, [7], [8]Palagi, E.; Nicotra, V.; Cordoni, G. (2015). Nevertheless, findings appear to indicate that relationship-seeking behavior in human-dog partnerships parallels the observations of Newcomb and Morry regarding human interpersonal attraction. Incredible moment a service dog stops its owner from having anxiety attack. The results suggest that attachment avoidance may facilitate the development of separation anxiety in dogs. In addition, their research provided other pertinent results. Lately, I’ve wished I had a best friend who is a vet—someone who could give me an honest, unbiased opinion not from a business or professional perspective, but from a place of truly compassionate and candid advising to ease the helplessness and confusion I’ve faced. 2009;81(3):383–391. The Relationship Between Owner and Dog Anxiety. Some of the greatest anxiety I’ve encountered has come from juggling the grief that comes with knowing my dog is reaching his life expectancy and dealing with an irreversible and fatal disease, all the while managing the guilt I experience when questioning whether it’s worth it to shell out $600-plus every six months, per the vet’s recommendation, for echocardiograms that will monitor the progression but not actually stop it. The disorganized parent may at times be responsive and at other times nonresponsive or erratically respond with passivity, aggression, or fear. Gazing behavior from dogs increases urinary oxytocin concentration in owners, which facilitates owner affiliation and subsequently increases oxytocin concentration in dogs. PMID 8427480., [5]Jeronimus BF, Riese H, Sanderman R, Ormel J (October 2014). Fear-based anxiety. In my opinion, the reason often is social self-validation. In a study of 13,700 Finnish pet dogs, there were large breed differences in the prevalence of all anxiety-related traits, suggesting a strong genetic contribution. If you have a dog that struggles with fear, anxiety, or stress, it’s important to be supportive and patient.. [CrossRef], [21]Kotrschal K, Schöberl I, Bauer B, Thibeaut AM, Wedl M. Dyadic relationships and operational performance of male and female owners and their male dogs. The “Domestication Syndrome” in Mammals:  A Unified Explanation Based on Neural Crest Cell Behavior and Genetics. The children tend to avoid and resist the caregiver and exhibit disorientation and confusion. Socialization programs need to be age appropriate and consider critical periods of emotional development, fear imprint periods, and the distinct temperament and behavior of the individual puppy or dog. The help of my own therapist really made a difference in that time of my life. Their dogs might urinate, defecate, bark, howl, chew, dig or try to escape. Gaze-mediated bonding exists between dogs and humans. I share this in hopes other pet owners who relate can recognize that the strong emotions they feel regarding their pet’s care, health, and life are valid. Provided the test is valid and performed by an experienced professional, puppy tests can have substantial longitudinal consistency. Thoughts of, “I’m never owning another pet again” creep in and I question whether the anxiety of anticipatory grief or actual grief is worse. Vol. In addition, analysis revealed significant differences in bone growth between the intact and neutered groups. However, if you are an anxious person, there are still ways that you can make sure your dog is as anxiety-free as possible. [82]  Moreover, the canine fMRI neuroscience research conducted by Berns and Spivak in Atlanta, GA and by the Miklosi Lab in Budapest, Hungary provide numerous examples of the similarities between the structure and function of dog and human brains. About a year and a half ago, my dog was diagnosed with congestive heart failure. I share this in hopes other pet owners who relate can recognize that the strong emotions they feel regarding their pet’s care, health, and life are valid. They all become an integral part of the family, and their loss is always a time of much grief and anxiety, but those feelings only show how much we have loved them. In addition, during an open field test, the presence of a tactile maternal source even if it was the cloth surrogate, increased exploratory behavior, whereas in the absence of the actual or surrogate caregiver the baby monkey was hesitant or afraid to explore, refused to move, and in the case of the surrogate-raised monkeys, often performed neurotic, compulsive thumb sucking. Attach., [48]McLeod, S.  Attachment Theory. [97] Relationship quality and perceived similarity provide psychological benefits for the perceiver. Bela Szandelszky/AP Updated at … Journal of Personality. doi:10.1111/j.1467-6494.1997.tb00531.x. However, ethologists and veterinarians universally believed that neutering reduced the probability of aggression in male dogs. For people, anxiety can feel overwhelming and debilitating at times. 2011;45(4):345–357. Losing Pepper has affected me so badly and I don’t know how to settle the sense of dread about the others. I will never forget the difference she made and I often struggle with feeling as if I failed her somehow despite all I did to try and help her. The following are excerpts from the article:[76]. PMID 9143146., [105]Zeigler-Hill, V.; Highfill, L. Applying the interpersonal circumplex to the behavioural styles of dogs and cats. [33]  With owners scoring higher on attachment-avoidance the occurrence of separation anxiety disorder increases. “Empathy: its ultimate and proximate bases” (PDF)., [78]Nagasawa, M; Mitsui, S; En, S; Ohtani, N; Ohta, M; Sakuma, Y; Onaka, T; Mogi, K; Kikusui, T.  Oxytocin-Gaze Positive Loop and the Coevolution of Human-Dog Bonds. ISSN 1939-1315. [11], One of the more significant human state anxieties relevant to the ontogenesis of a pet dog is social anxiety. Dec 27, 2011., [50]Harlow, H. F. (1958). In contrast, aroused dogs are more likely to exhibit aggressive behavior. Oct 9, 2015., [43] Suomi, S. J. and Leroy, H. A. Age-based anxiety can happen when a dog’s normal routine is changed. Or now that we have greater knowledge of owner-dog relationship dynamics is there something we can do to minimize problematic outcomes and incidences of dog-human and dog-dog aggression? When I talk to a dog owner who has a separation anxiety dog, the biggest message I initially want to get across is that this is a fear, phobia, panic about being left alone. Oct 9, 2015., [40]New Jr., J.C., Salman, M.D., King, M., Scarlett, J.M., Kass, P.H. “Empathy: its ultimate and proximate bases” (PDF). “Interpersonal attraction and personality: What is attractive – self similarity, ideal similarity, complementarity, or attachment security?”. ; Shaver, P.R. Nevertheless, the Elaboration Principle is not highly relevant to the focus of our discussion. From a behavioral perspective they began behaving like domestic dogs. Evaluations maximize the probability that a selected candidate animal will be an optimal match for the client. September 2017. However, can an anxious dog create an anxious owner? [79], The simulation theory of empathy posits that capable organisms understand the behavior of others by activating mental processes that, if carried into action, would produce similar behavior. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science,1, 207-226., [42]Weiss, E; Gramann, S; Spain, CV; Slater, M. Goodbye to a Good Friend: An Explanation of the Re-homing of Cats and Dogs in the U.S.  Research and Development, American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. Permission to publish granted by Megan MacCutcheon, LPC, therapist in Vienna, Virginia. In summary, it should be clear how an avoidant owner has a higher probability of owning an anxious and aggressive dog. PMID 12625087., [83], [84]Theodore Mead Newcomb. [CrossRef], [112]Jones, A.C.; Gosling, S.D. 15: 49–61. J Res Pers. Calming a frequently anxious dog is possible, but it may require collaboration between you and your veterinarian, or a board-certified veterinary behaviorist.. March 31, 2020., [61], [62]Belyaev’s Farm Fox Experiment. The following video explains the Big 5 personality types defined by Goldberg: Now that we comprehend the definition of neuroticism and can envision practical applications where neuroticism is maladaptive, let’s consider why and how a neurotic owner can transmit his/her neurotic tendencies to a household dog. The Similarity Principle states that persons tend to join groups that contain members who are similar to the person in values, attitudes, beliefs, races, gender, age, and other demographic factors. [Google Scholar],, [20]Podberscek, A.L. I was utterly traumatised and have since moved house. Newcomb explained the Proximity Principle as emanating from persons usually preferring what is familiar and the tendency for persons to have more frequent exposure repetition with those that reside proximally. • 12% of abandoned dogs had bitten a person. The Silver Fox Domestication Experiment. Moreover, the earlier the dog was neutered the more negative the effect on behavior and orthopedic development. March 2001. Extrapolating further, when persons with general anxiety or social anxiety are exposed to social contexts they have an elevated probability of responding fearfully or even with panic., [44]Harry Harlow.” A Science Odyssey. Here is an excellent video by the Khan Academy that explains Similarity-Attraction principles: Thus, in accordance with Newcomb’s Similarity Principle and Morry’s Attraction-Similarity Model, people seek persons they believe are like themselves. Nov 15, 2016., [109]Russ, T; Stamatakis, E; Hamer, M; Starr, J; Kivimaki, M; Batty, GD. [88]  Two conditions that promote interpersonal attraction between members of a dyad are perceived similarity of alter to self and interpersonal congruency. [1]Gobbo, E, Zupan, M, Dog’s Sociability, Owners’ Neuroticism, and Attachment Style to Pets as Predictors of Dog Aggression, Animals, Feb 18, 2020., [2], [3], [4]Goldberg LR (January 1993). Please fill out all required fields to submit your message. Anatomical structure will usually remain fairly consistent within a breed, although it may vary somewhat between lines within a breed. ISSN 2054-5703. Bowlby described 4 primary attachment styles: 1) Secure attachment– occurs when the primary caregiver promptly, dependably, and sensitively provides physical and emotional comfort to the infant. Consequently, the logical conclusion is that human owners exhibiting a neurotic emotional state or neurotic behavior may infect their dogs with homologous state anxiety and concomitant anxiety-related behaviors. Pers. Scientific Reports. [83][84], The Proximity Principle states that persons tend to associate with, befriend, and be attracted to persons that are nearby. Perceived 
personality matching in owner–dog dyads. Should old dog trainers learn new tricks? In Touch in Early Development, Field TM, ed. “The structure of phenotypic personality traits”. As discussed in previous sections, owner personality type and attachment style can affect the emotional development, emotional state, and behavior of the puppy or dog. July 17, 2019., [29]Mariti, C.; Gazzano, A.; Ricci, E.; Zilocchi, M. Owners as a secure base for their dogs. [93], Marian Morry, a psychology professor and head of the Close Relationship Laboratory at the University of Manitoba, expanded upon Newcomb’s work. The answer lies in the principles of emotional contagion discussed in Section IIa. Again, after more than a month of uncertainty and worry and pain for me and my dog, my boxer’s issue has come back just the same and the cycle is killing me, it feels like. picking up car keys) and re-teaching the dog that the ‘routine’ no longer predicts departure. (2002). PLoS One. In addition, the study identified several breed differences, suggesting a genetic contribution to social fearfulness. [71]  In addition, interspecies emotional communication can become contagious via olfactory chemosignals. One of my (young) cats was killed in September when my ex accidently closed our garage door on her. “Neuroticism is associated with larger and more prolonged electrodermal responses to emotionally evocative pictures”(PDF). Perceived, not actual, similarity predicts initial attraction in a live 
romantic context: Evidence from the speed- dating paradigm. Prevention is optimal to minimize the probability of future problems. Dog Fear and Anxiety: What Every Dog Owner Needs To Know. Dogs gonadectomized between the ages of 7 – 12 months of age were 26% more likely to demonstrate aggression toward strangers. Complementarity was associated with more positive regard and more group integration in bands consisting of musicians who were high in interpersonal rigidity, whereas the effect was less strong in bands consisting of musicians who were lower in rigidity. Are neurotic owners purposefully acquiring anxious dogs that mirror the owner’s personality type? [PubMed] [Google Scholar],, [22]Egan, V.; MacKenzie, J. [48][49], Harlow also performed notable later experiments to study the effects of social isolation on the formation of depression. Separation anxiety peeing in dogs takes place when the owner leaves the home. And I recognize the greatest factor in my anxiety is in anticipating my dog’s impending passing and knowing there is no course of action that will eliminate facing this hurdle. [7]  Emotional contagion is a basic form of empathy that makes individuals able to experience others’ emotions. [PubMed] [Google Scholar],, [19]Fugazza C, Miklósi A. Interestingly, the study correlated another characteristic germane to deleterious outcomes. Greater friendship satisfaction predicted greater perceived friend-self similarity. She was with me for 14 years and had arrived in my life at a difficult period in my life where she became therapy for me. Questions or concerns about the preceding article can be directed to the author or posted as a comment below. Consequently, to obtain the highest probability of obtaining a puppy or dog of optimal temperament, aptitude, and structure, we highly recommend that anyone visiting a breeder, shelter, or rescue solicit a CPT professional evaluation prior to completing a purchase or adoption. Mary Ainsworth, an American-Canadian developmental psychologist, created the “strange-situation” test most frequently used by psychologists and researchers to measure attachment. JSTOR 2667070,, [76]Hare, B; Woods, V.  Opinion:  We Didn’t Domesticate Dogs They Domesticated Us. Cover Photo Credit: Welcome Library, London. Behavioral and Brain Sciences. CPT behavior modification programs can do wonders in improving the emotional state and behavior of an anxious and/or aggressive dog. Highly Heritable and Functionally Relevant Breed Differences in Dog Behavior. Relaxed dogs are rarely prone to aggressive behavior. [80]  Thus, simulation theory explains our ability to comprehend and empathize with the emotional state and behavior of others and to intentionally affect the emotions and behavior of others.[81]. All this in just one lesson! 2) Ambivalent attachment– occurs when the primary caregiver inconsistently and unreliably attends to the infant’s physical and emotional needs, where she is at times responsive and at other times neglectful. From an overall psychological standpoint, the children are disposed to anger, helplessness, passivity, and general insecurity. Owning a pet can be wonderful. Chronic stress reduces the pet’s physical and psychological health, spawns illnesses, and reduces lifespan. Your dog could have separation anxiety. It is more than a … There will be deviations from the norm, even significant deviations, within certain lines and specific individuals. Applied Animal Behaviour Science. [58], A study of 17,000 dogs concluded that a large proportion of variance in dog behavior is attributable to genetic factors. Let’s begin answering the section header question by discussing theories of attraction. And from the standpoint of anxiety reduction, a trained dog is a happy dog and belongs to a happy owner. Pet ownership, rewarding as it can be, can be a source of great stress and anxiety and is a valid reason to seek support when needed. Oct 31, 2019., [74]Amici, F; Waterman, J; Kellerman, CM; Karimullah; K, Brauer, J. But there is help and support out there. 18(1): 125-143. I have a personal theory regarding why anxious owners tend to select anxious pets, even though cognitively they may realize there is a greater potential for detrimental outcomes. For instance, a group of leaders will need followers and conversely a group of followers will need leaders. These things have little or no impact on s… • Abandoned dogs were less likely than continued dogs to receive veterinary care. Touch during infancy reduces corticosteroid levels and increases the number of glucorticoid receptors in the central nervous system. Via one or a combination of group class, private instruction, and/or board training CPT can design and implement a customized socialization development program that is optimized for each pet. Here is an excellent video of monkey responses in Harlow’s lab: Later study provided a scientific explanation for Harlow’s experiments and the practical observations of attachment theory in humans and dogs. An anxiety jacket (such as the Thundershirt Dog Anxiety Jacket from Amazon) is a relatively new idea in treating this condition in dogs. In addition, dogs scoring higher in the neuroticism scale were more prone to develop separation anxiety disorder. One of the questions, we frequently receive is, “Should I spay/neuter my pet?”  Clients also frequently ask, “When should I spay neuter my pet?”  The answers are not always simple. The preceding hypothesis is in line with human-human similarity-attraction models, as one of the benefits of similar attraction espoused by social psychologists is the validation one receives by achieving acceptance from similar people. [18]  Dogs are skillful in acquiring information socially from humans and are able to copy the actions of a human demonstrator. [CrossRef], [23], [24], [25]David L. “Attachment Theory (Bowlby),” in Learning Theories, January 24, 2016., [26]Cherry, K.  “Bowlby & Ainsworth:  What is Attachment Theory? © Copyright Mark Spivak and Comprehensive Pet Therapy, Inc.  April 2020.
2020 dog owner anxiety